Skip to content

Major Changes to the BIA Appeal Process

bia appeal

On November 17, 2026, the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) issued a final rule which will overhaul the BIA Appeal process for persons who are appealing the decision of an Immigration Judge or the DHS issued on or after December 17, 2026.

Under the new rule, a single BIA member will initially review the appeal.  The appeal will be dismissed unless a majority of BIA members vote to accept the case for full briefing.

In most cases, the BIA appeal period will be shortened from 30 to 10 days.    However, if the immigration judge denied an asylum claim on its merits, the person will still have 30 days to file an appeal to the BIA.

The new 10-day deadline applies in the following situations:

  • Asylum was denied because of a one-year filing deadline bar.
  • Asylum was denied due to a safe third country or asylum cooperative agreement.
  • Asylum was denied because of a prior asylum denial.
  • The case involves withholding-only or CAT-only proceedings.
  • The appeal involves any form of relief other than asylum, such as cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, waivers, bond, or other immigration judge decisions such as those relating to removability, termination or administration closure.
  • It is unclear which deadline applies when a case involves both an asylum denial on the merits and a denial of another form of relief, such as cancellation of removal. Practitioners should assume that in this situation they will want to file the notice of appeal within 10 days to preserve review of the cancellation of removal application in addition to the asylum claim.

The BIA will only consider issues which are listed in the Notice of Appeal.

The rule removes that requirement that Immigration Judges review hearing transcripts before the BIA considers the appeal.

As a former INS Trial Attorney, I consider the BIA appeal regulation to be a serious violation of due process of law.  People without attorneys, many of whom are in detention, will not be able to hire attorneys and file appeals to the BIA within 10 days.

Client Reviews

Legal Guru in All Things Immigration

“Mr. Shusterman and his law firm have represented my family and me very successfully. He is not only a legal guru in all things immigration but even more so he is an exceptional human being because he empathizes with his clients and cares that justice is done.”

- Maria Davari Knapp
Read More Reviews

Zoom Consultations Available!

The reason the government is issuing this regulation is simple: In fiscal year 2017, the BIA’s pending caseload was a little over 35,000 cases.  Today, it is over 325,000 cases.

Yet, the government has reduced the number of members of the BIA from 28 last year to 15 today.

The solution is not to deprive persons of their right to Due Process of Law.  EOIR should expect legal challenges to it’s BIA appeal regulation.

BIA Appeals – Related Links:

arvo rating shusterman law v2Best Lawyers in America Carl Shusterman Law
Super Lawyers Shusterman LawLexis Nexis Peer Review Rated Shusterman Law